Global Food Crisis: A Bowl of Opportunities for Muslim World
Dinar Standard | 3 November 2008
By Rafi-uddin Shikoh & Shuriah Niazi
While developed countries are directing their attention to the turmoil in the financial sector - far less attention is being paid to the global food price crisis--- a crisis that is having a more immediate and life threatening impact on the global masses.
According to a recent report from Oxfam, a global non-governmental organizations working to fight poverty, prices of staple foods have seen increases ranging from 30 per cent to 150 per cent in 2007 and 2008. The impact of which, according to the World Bank, has increased the number of malnourished people worldwide by 119 million in 2007 and 2008 bringing the total to nearly one billion people (967 million) worldwide.
From Egypt, Indonesia, Bangladesh, and Sudan, to Pakistan--many Muslim majority countries are facing some of the worst pains of this global crisis. For example, Oxfam's recent report, "Food Crisis in Pakistan: Real or Artificial", says the number of poor in the country has risen from 60 to 77 million since 2007 because of food inflation. Infact food related riots have been seen in many of these countries. Ironically, it's these same economies which are some of the most agriculturally endowed in the world.
According to the UN's Food & Agricultural Organization, Pakistan is the world's top producer of buffalo/goat milk (#2/#4), buffalo/ goat meat (#2), chick-peas (#2), and sugar cane (#5); Bangladesh is a leading producer of rice (#4), jute (#2), goat milk/meat (#2, #4); and Indonesia is a leading producer of coconuts (#1), green beans (#2), tropical fruits (#2), eggs (#3), and rice (#3) in addition to many other agricultural products.
Conversely, the oil-rich Muslim majority states of the Arabian Gulf have become the biggest beneficiaries of the other global crisis - the energy shortage. Record revenue windfalls have eased the impact of the food crisis in these countries. As these Gulf and other oil rich Muslim economies look to invest their revenue windfall towards domestic infrastructure and industrial rehauling-the agriculturally endowed, yet poorer Muslim world economies provide a unique investment opportunity for them.
This analysis looks at how the oil-rich Muslim economies could leverage their existing relationships with agriculture based Muslim economies (which have a wide productivity gap with the worlds net agriculture exporters) taking them to globally competitive levels; reaping for themselves high investment returns, securing their own food sources, and contributing to alleviation of the food crisis from other Muslim countries.
The Impact and Drivers
We are all feeling the pinch from rising food prices. For us-the fortunate ones - who can afford internet access and read magazines-- the food crisis may translate into eating out less, or cutting down on buying expensive groceries. However, for approximately 2.7 billion of the world's population who spend 80% of their income on food (source: Oxfam)-this is serious. In Pakistan, the poorest one-fifth of the country's population spends 50 to 58 per cent of its income on buying cereal foods alone. The skyrocketing wheat prices, therefore, becomes a matter of life and death for the extremely poor.
This dramatic spike in food prices has been attributed to various complex and interlocking reasons. Growing global demand (particularly from large, emerging economies such as China and India), unfair world trade rules, skimpy wheat harvests, speculation in the commodities market, increased use of farmland to produce bio fuels (to offset high fuel prices), years of neglect in investing in agricultural sectors, and climate change are all playing a part.
The global push for bio fuel crops, which then take food crops out of production, is playing a significant role in raising prices. World Bank analysts have estimated that bio fuel production has accounted for 65 percent in the rise of world food prices, while the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has concluded that bio fuel production is responsible for a significant part of the jump in commodity prices.
Another significant contributor is the growing global demand for products like meat and grain, and a corresponding lack of supply. Years of under-investment in agriculture in poorer countries, and unfair trade rules and farming policies that benefit rich countries, also contribute to this negative impact.
"The real matter to my mind is growing consumption - whether it is food or energy. We need to cut down wasteful consumption," said B.G. Vergese, a noted Indian economic analyst.
The objective of this article is not to analyze the reasons of the crisis, since broadly it all boils down to supply and demand disparities. Rather, our focus is to concentrate on the unique opportunities in the market.
The Muslim World - Agriculture Centered but Food Poor
Many of the 57 OIC (Organization of Islamic Conference) member countries are agriculture centered economies producing a major portion of the world's food commodities. As shown in the table below--Indonesia, Pakistan, Turkey, Iran, and Egypt have the biggest agriculture outputs within the Muslim world (by GDP - PPP contribution.)
Most of these top agricultural based economies are also some of the poorest and hardest hit by the food crisis. Within the ten major agricultural Muslim world economies, Bangladesh, Sudan, Nigeria, Pakistan and Indonesia have the lowest GDP Per capita (PPP.)
An Opportunity to Lead
While these are some of the poorest economies in the world,they stand to benefit greatly from a growing demand for food. In Indonesia, according to Oxfam, the price rises have offered a huge opportunity for palm oil exports: these increased by 55 per cent in 2007, making palm oil the country's biggest revenue-generating export, surpassing even copper, coal, oil, and gas. At the same time, Indonesia being a beneficiary of the booming bio fuels sector is experiencing a soaring price of local cooking oil, making everyday life very difficult for its people.
A key aspect of the opportunity here is the low agricultural productivity of these economies that forms the basis of the potential. When compared to the global leaders in agricultural exports, the agricultural productivity of Muslim majority agricultural economies lags far behind. Amongst the largest 10 agricultural economies Egypt, Bangladesh and Pakistan are the most productive when measured by the $ Agricultural output/ square km, whereas Sudan, Nigeria, Algeria and Turkey are the least productive.
The low value productivity has been attributed by various agencies to under-investment in the agricultural sector, government mismanagement, and not being able to attune the agricultural practices to the developing world.
Thus the number one opportunity is for these very countries' public and private sectors to commit to agricultural development and lead the world in fulfilling global food demand.
Another unique aspect of this opportunity is the role of the Oil-rich Muslim majority countries. The most affluent Muslim majority countries (based on GDP per capita) are almost all the oil producing nations of the GCC (Gulf Cooperation Council) that have benefited from the cash windfall of world oil dependent energy needs.
The total population of the six members of the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) - Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and the UAE - rose from around 30 million in 2000 to more than 35 million in 2006. GCC food imports cost 10 billion dollars in 2007 where Saudi Arabia, with a population of about 24 million, remains the largest food importer. As the table below shows, the GCC countries that are looking to diversify their investments can contribute and benefit greatly by investing in the great agricultural sector potential of the Muslim world economies. This also will help them secure their own food supply needs.
Emerging Private Sector Investments & Government Initiatives
There are certainly indications that the Muslim world is taking some actions to tap into the above stated potential.
At the Government level, recently, the 57 nations of the Organization of the Islamic Conference have come together to cooperate on increasing food production. Kuwait's Deputy Prime Minister Sheikh Dr Mohammad Sabah Al-Salem Al-Sabah has recently said that Muslim countries were the most gravely affected by developmental challenges, namely global inflation and shortages in the world's food reserves.
This has compelled the Kuwait Government to launch several initiatives such as Kuwait's "decent living" fund. The Amir of Kuwait has donated $ 100 million to establish the fund for "decent living" in Muslim countries, and another $ 300 million to the Islamic Development Bank's (IDB) Poverty Fund.
Meanwhile, the Islamic Development Bank (IDB) has also pledged USD 1.5 billion toward addressing the food crisis in its poorest member countries. The package, known as the Jeddah Declaration, will be disbursed over a 5-year period and will include short, medium, and long-term programs to deal with the crisis.
Faced with a scarcity of fertile land, water shortages and surging world food prices, the GCC states are seeking to secure their food supplies by investing in agriculture abroad. Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates, the top food importers among GCC countries, are now looking to Asia and Africa as opportunities for agricultural investments.
On the private sector side, it seems that many GCC companies are looking at establishing agricultural ventures in other nearby countries.
One reported UAE project to develop more than 70,000 acres (28,328 hectares) of arable land in Sudan is in line with this strategy. Being Africa's largest country, it has abundant water resources including the Nile River, the world's longest river. However, Sudanese agriculture remains massively underdeveloped, although it employs 80 percent of the workforce, with much of the population reliant on subsistence agriculture.
Egypt and Pakistan have also been targeted by Saudi Arabia and the UAE for food projects.
Some recent transactions/ initiatives are as follows (Source: http://www.grain.org/go/landgrab):
- In August 2008, three Gulf firms -- Abu Dhabi Investment House, Ithmaar Bank and Gulf Finance House – announced the creation of AgriCapital, a new Islamic investment fund. The US$1bn investment vehicle will engage in land purchases overseas to produce food for the region.
- MAP (Market Access Promotion) Services Group, an international investment firm, has joined other Gulf partners to form a Middle East Food Fund that will collectively invest in food production in nearby countries for the Gulf market. MAP will also develop 10 model dairy and livestock farms in Pakistan through private equity, small enterprise development and donor facilitation in 2008–10.
- On 7 September 2008, Kuwait’s Minister of Finance signed what his Sudanese counterpart called a “giant” strategic partnership deal with the government in Khartoum. Under the agreement, the two will invest jointly in food production, presumably in Sudan, including cattle.
- The Qatar Company for Meat and Livestock Trading Mawashi has established a sheep farm in western Sudan and has signed a memorandum of understanding with the country for further expansion in livestock farming. It also has bilateral agreements with two Tajik livestock companies. Qatar Livestock Mawashi has also committed US$1bn to develop industrial livestock farms in Pakistan.
- In August 2008, the BinLaden Group signed an agreement to invest at least US$4.3bn, on behalf of a consortium of 15 Saudi investors known as the Middle East Foodstuff Consortium, to develop 500,000 ha of riceland in Indonesia.
- Hail Agricultural Development Company (HADCO), a Saudi agribusiness firm, has leased 25,000 acres (10,117 ha) for US$95m north of Khartoum to produce food and feed for export to Saudi Arabia.
- Abraaj Capital, a private equity firm managing US$5bn of assets, has, together with the UAE government, reportedly acquired some 800,000 acres (about 324,000 ha) of supposedly “barren” farmland in Pakistan over the last year to produce rice and wheat for export to UAE.
Envisioning a food market to the world
There are certainly many, many challenges in improving the productivity of the agriculturally endowed Muslim world economies. Ineffective management of water resources, soil fertility; in effective access to markets, credit and input; and lack of R&D are all known hurdles.
However, given the already existing strong relationship of the GCC countries with agriculturally endowed Muslim world economies and the investment pool available, the GCC countries can take a leadership / innovative role with a coordinated investment strategy that supports government driven strategies as well as individual farming practices while resulting in their its own food supplies as well as investment returns.
In many ways this type of leadership is akin to Dubai's very impressive world leading approach to becoming the new world tourism destination and the rest are following. Perhaps a spirited human impacting vision could also enable it to steer and lead establishing the Muslim world as the leading food basket to the world.
Post a comment